Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Rspca Back Calls For Immediate End To Bsl
Dogz Online Forums > Discussion Forums > General Dog Discussion
Erny
RSPCA call back on BSL Law - UK

QUOTE
In a landmark event, the UK's largest animal welfare charity the RSPCA has joined forces with DDAWatch and the Coalition For improved Dog Ownership Standards (CFIDOS) to publicly call for an end to the unfair law that results in dogs being deemed 'dangerous' as a result of their physical appearance.

For the first time, the UK's most promiment animal welfare organisation has been prepared to publicly support calls for a repeal of section 1 of the Dangerous Dogs Act (DDA) - Section 1 is the part of the legislation which bans dogs based on their breed or type.

Section 1 of the 1991 Dangerous Dogs Act is a highly controversial and widely criticised clause that promotes breed specific legislation. Many experts, law makers and dog lovers from around the UK and globally have seen the devastation caused by breed specific legislation - which outlaws dogs by 'type', meaning a dog is deemed 'dangerous' and illegal simply based on what it looks like and not because of any offence caused by the dog. As a result of breed specific legislation (BSL) in the UK, many innocent dogs have lost their lives since the law was brought in by Ken Baker in 1991.

Now the RSPCA has set the wheels in motion for other prominent welfare groups to come out and publicly call on the law makers to end section 1 and replace it with fair, effective dog laws which do not condemn dogs to death based on what the look like. The UK can put itself in a position to follow the example set by the Netherlands in repealing section 1 in favour of a law that will place the burden of responsibility on owners rather than terminating the lives of dogs who are guilty of nothing more than looking a certain way.

The move comes about following a productive and engaging meeting between the RSPCA's Government Relations Manager, Claire Robinson, DDAWatch and the C- fidos at the end of 2008.

The RSPCA public backing for repeal gives anti BSL campaigners the boost they have been waiting for while sending a clear message to the Government that section 1 of the DDA is a failed, unfair concept that needs to be reformed without delay.

DDAWatch - an anti BSL campaign group - has congratulated the RSPCA on the decision to call for action having been previously disheartened to hear many organisations publicly state anti BSL positions but falling short of actually calling for an immediate repeal of section 1.

Alison Green of DDAWatch:

"We are so thrilled to see the RSPCA step up to the plate on such an important issue that has cost the lives of many innocent dogs. For those people who have been actively involved in fighting section 1 cases, for those of us who've seen dog owner's lives ripped apart by this appalling law, which has not protected the public at all, this announcement from the RSPCA will hopefully herald the start of many more calls for repeal and eventually the repeal itself. Now owners and anti BSL campaigners alike have some hope to cling to after so many false dawns. Now we have the opportunity of a lifetime to finally get the Government to see sense. They need to listen to the RSPCA and make the right call. Section 1 has been an unmitigated failure and an animal welfare disaster. It is such a relief to hear the RSPCA being brave and honest enough to publicly call for a repeal where other influential and supposedly anti BSL organisations have fallen short, instead citing 'political climate' as a reason to keep BSL."

Ryan O'Meara, chief executive of C-fidos:

"This is truly great news. It seems such a simple thing to do, to publicly support an end to BSL - especially given that the RSPCA and other major animal welfare organisations have publicly stated their position as being anti BSL - but despite the anti BSL positions held by many organisations and individuals we still have BSL and we have it because we still have section 1 of the DDA. The way to end BSL is to end section 1 and replace it. The RSPCA coming in with public support for the position held by C-fidos and DDAWatch gives legitimacy and momentum to campaigners to call on their government to end BSL. It's no longer a concept, being anti BSL, it's a real, tangible opportunity to call the government to account over a highly unfair, unpopular and completely unsuccessful law."


OMG!! Go RSPCA UK!! clap.gif
db_sampson
this is an excellent call be the RSPCA UK, think its still a long way off happening here though...
The Spotted Devil
Wow eek1.gif
bulldogz4eva
Bit of a turn around isnt it.Its only taken them 18 years.At least they have seen the light.Hope it is the tide of change.
Erny
It's a beginning. And that's something many didn't think they'd ever live to see.

It's a beginning. And if the RSPCA over there is anything like the RSPCA here in Victoria, it will have its way biggrin.gif.
rhapsodical78
That is very exciting news. I can only hope that this eventually constitutes a catalyst for lasting change to BSL.
mantis
Well Hugh Wirthless has now left the RSPCA, so hopefully Australia won't be far behind ending BSL. thumbsup1.gif
Sam&Saki
Yay!!!!!!!

Hopefully Aus RSPCA will follow thumbsup1.gif
The Spotted Devil
QUOTE (mantis @ 7th Jan 2009 - 11:55 PM) *
Well Hugh Wirthless has now left the RSPCA, so hopefully Australia won't be far behind ending BSL. thumbsup1.gif


Really? I thought he was still involved with RSPCA Vic confused.gif
mantis
QUOTE (The Spotted Devil @ 7th Jan 2009 - 11:59 PM) *
QUOTE (mantis @ 7th Jan 2009 - 11:55 PM) *
Well Hugh Wirthless has now left the RSPCA, so hopefully Australia won't be far behind ending BSL. thumbsup1.gif


Really? I thought he was still involved with RSPCA Vic confused.gif


I was told he is no longer in charge, I hope that is right, otherwise things wn't change here until he's gone. crying.gif

Can anyone confirm if he is still in charge?
The Spotted Devil
QUOTE (mantis @ 8th Jan 2009 - 12:15 AM) *
QUOTE (The Spotted Devil @ 7th Jan 2009 - 11:59 PM) *
QUOTE (mantis @ 7th Jan 2009 - 11:55 PM) *
Well Hugh Wirthless has now left the RSPCA, so hopefully Australia won't be far behind ending BSL. thumbsup1.gif


Really? I thought he was still involved with RSPCA Vic confused.gif


I was told he is no longer in charge, I hope that is right, otherwise things wn't change here until he's gone. crying.gif

Can anyone confirm if he is still in charge?


Still listed as President (RSPCA Vic) on RSPCA Australia website....happy to be corrected.
mantis
QUOTE (The Spotted Devil @ 8th Jan 2009 - 12:30 AM) *
QUOTE (mantis @ 8th Jan 2009 - 12:15 AM) *
QUOTE (The Spotted Devil @ 7th Jan 2009 - 11:59 PM) *
QUOTE (mantis @ 7th Jan 2009 - 11:55 PM) *
Well Hugh Wirthless has now left the RSPCA, so hopefully Australia won't be far behind ending BSL. thumbsup1.gif


Really? I thought he was still involved with RSPCA Vic confused.gif


I was told he is no longer in charge, I hope that is right, otherwise things wn't change here until he's gone. crying.gif

Can anyone confirm if he is still in charge?


Still listed as President (RSPCA Vic) on RSPCA Australia website....happy to be corrected.


swear2.gif swear2.gif swear2.gif
mita
QUOTE (db_sampson @ 7th Jan 2009 - 10:33 PM) *
this is an excellent call be the RSPCA UK, think its still a long way off happening here though...


Are you sure about that? Terrorbull, in the thread about the latest dog attack, posted this, that she heard in the media.

"Chick from the RSPCA "its the deed, not the breed, even Lassie will Bite under the right circumstances""

Few years back, the CEO RSPCA Qld went public in the newspapers here, saying that the BSL laws were a tragedy.....just leading to innocent family dogs being put down.

The new Domestic Animals Act being tabled in Qld is correcting a 'breed' specific approach by emphasising responsible & knowledgeable management of dogs.

Teebs

And im trying to find a video of that chick who said that with no luck.

Its a start... lets all hope it works and others follow
mita
QUOTE (Terrorbull @ 8th Jan 2009 - 08:33 AM) *
And im trying to find a video of that chick who said that with no luck.

Its a start... lets all hope it works and others follow


TB, was the lass from RSPCA NSW? Why I ask is that I saw a brilliant article about the foolishness of BSL laws written by the NSW EDBA president (I think) in Dogs Life magazine. It was followed by an article where someone from RSPCA NSW gave their views.....& it had many of the same points that the EDBA had said. I thought that was a huge leap forward.
Teebs
I am sure it was from Qld. I might jump on the site now and email them, see if they have the video online


ETA i just emailed them, will wait and see
Ci
Wow - that's pretty big!!!!

Ci
Wow - that's pretty big!!!!

mita
QUOTE (Terrorbull @ 8th Jan 2009 - 08:55 AM) *
I am sure it was from Qld. I might jump on the site now and email them, see if they have the video online


ETA i just emailed them, will wait and see


Here's hoping you get a response.

If she was from RSPCA Qld it fits with the changed approach in the new Domestic Animals law that turns the tables on BSL & emphasises owner responsibility & management of their dogs. The RSPCA was one of the number of stakeholders that sat around a table & nutted out that law. The greyhound people also contributed, giving a great new deal to greys as pets.
addy001
this is great news, hopefully things will start to change here
The Spotted Devil
QUOTE (mantis @ 8th Jan 2009 - 12:33 AM) *
QUOTE (The Spotted Devil @ 8th Jan 2009 - 12:30 AM) *
QUOTE (mantis @ 8th Jan 2009 - 12:15 AM) *
QUOTE (The Spotted Devil @ 7th Jan 2009 - 11:59 PM) *
QUOTE (mantis @ 7th Jan 2009 - 11:55 PM) *
Well Hugh Wirthless has now left the RSPCA, so hopefully Australia won't be far behind ending BSL. thumbsup1.gif


Really? I thought he was still involved with RSPCA Vic confused.gif


I was told he is no longer in charge, I hope that is right, otherwise things wn't change here until he's gone. crying.gif

Can anyone confirm if he is still in charge?


Still listed as President (RSPCA Vic) on RSPCA Australia website....happy to be corrected.


swear2.gif swear2.gif swear2.gif


I suspect, from the conflicting opinions by RSPCA regarding the recent dog attack (any breed can attack vs Bullmastiffs are dangerous) that he's out on his own on this one. Someone needs to put their hand up for the RPSCA Vic president position.....but getting in is not that easy I understand...
Ci
From what I understand - its an old boys club! And you have to been chummy chummy.

About time for some flesh blood I think!
mita
QUOTE (The Spotted Devil @ 8th Jan 2009 - 09:35 AM) *
I suspect, from the conflicting opinions by RSPCA regarding the recent dog attack (any breed can attack vs Bullmastiffs are dangerous) that he's out on his own on this one. Someone needs to put their hand up for the RPSCA Vic president position.....but getting in is not that easy I understand...


I read on the RSPCA Victoria werbsite that he's been President since 1972.

"Dr Wirth has been a council member for RSPCA Victoria since 1969 and has been President since 1972."

Even if he were a genius on dog matters, it's not good for any organisation to have one person at the helm for so long.

What other RSPCA spokespeople have said, shows up-to-date knowledge about dog behaviour. And the law is catching up....as in the Qld Domestic Animal Act.

May even more up-to-date knowledge about dogs get into the public domain....from the mouths of stakeholders like the RSPCA. And may more enlightened laws (when necessary) follow.
Loraine
At last a modicum of sweet sanity - GO RSPCA UK and let the rest of the world fall in behind (quickly as you can) thumbsup1.gif
Erny
Support of the RSPCA UK's action from around the world is being noted ...... even your comments in this thread smile.gif.

http://www.dogmagazine.net/archives/1652/r...slation-stance/

QUOTE
RSPCA Commended For Breed Specific Legislation Stance

January 8, 2009 by Ryan O'Meara

The RSPCA has won plaudits from around the world for its public call for a repeal of section 1 of the Dangerous Dogs Act - the part that bans dogs based on what they look like.

Dave Holden, vice chair of the National Dog Warden Association said:

Well done RSPCA for publically stating that section one of the DDA needs to be repealed. it brings hope to every dog locked away on looks alone and to those who have fought hard for so long for just laws which do not discriminate against specific dogs, here and overseas.

From the USA:

Gives the words ‘Happy New Year’ a whole new meaning. Keep your paws crossed that other UK animal welfare orgs will be inspired to join the RSPCA in this statement.

I think I am in shock over the good fortune coming to our bullie friends in the UK. Such good news!


From Australia:

That is very exciting news. I can only hope that this eventually constitutes a catalyst for lasting change to BSL.

Wow - that’s pretty big!!!!

this is great news, hopefully things will start to change here

At last a modicum of sweet sanity - GO RSPCA UK and let the rest of the world fall in behind (quickly as you can)


Further to the public congratulations to the RSPCA move, emails have been steadily flowing from people who now have something to cling to and can see that they are not on their own in understanding the flaws in BSL as a concept.

For their part the RSPCA is keen to stress its point further. A spokesperson for the organisation told us:

“The focus must be on the deed and not the breed of the animal and enforcement of the law should be made as simple and effective as possible to ensure that local authorities and police services take action.

Section 1 of the Dangerous Dogs Act 1991 has had little effect to stem the number of prohibited dogs in the country and many experts believe there are more in the UK now than in the late 1980s and early 1990s.

The RSPCA is working with politicians to encourage support for such an approach to legislation and hopes in the long-term to be successful in this tact.”

Many will agree, this positive news is a great way to start the new year and let’s hope we can cite 2009 as the year when the legislators and major animal organisations worked together to put an end to the barbaric practice of state controlled killing and seizure of dogs based on nothing more than their size and shape - a practice which has not only cost the tax payer millions of pounds but has NOT reduced the number of dog attacks or improved the safety of the general public at all.
Author Details
Ryan O'Meara is editor-in-chief of K9 Magazine, the lifestyle magazine for dog lovers. He lives in the East Midlands with his own two dogs, Mia and Chloe.
rhapsodical78
QUOTE (Erny @ 8th Jan 2009 - 10:56 PM) *
Support of the RSPCA UK's action from around the world is being noted ...... even your comments in this thread smile.gif.

http://www.dogmagazine.net/archives/1652/r...slation-stance/

QUOTE
RSPCA Commended For Breed Specific Legislation Stance

January 8, 2009 by Ryan O'Meara

The RSPCA has won plaudits from around the world for its public call for a repeal of section 1 of the Dangerous Dogs Act - the part that bans dogs based on what they look like.

Dave Holden, vice chair of the National Dog Warden Association said:

Well done RSPCA for publically stating that section one of the DDA needs to be repealed. it brings hope to every dog locked away on looks alone and to those who have fought hard for so long for just laws which do not discriminate against specific dogs, here and overseas.

From the USA:

Gives the words ‘Happy New Year’ a whole new meaning. Keep your paws crossed that other UK animal welfare orgs will be inspired to join the RSPCA in this statement.

I think I am in shock over the good fortune coming to our bullie friends in the UK. Such good news!


From Australia:

That is very exciting news. I can only hope that this eventually constitutes a catalyst for lasting change to BSL.

Wow - that’s pretty big!!!!

this is great news, hopefully things will start to change here

At last a modicum of sweet sanity - GO RSPCA UK and let the rest of the world fall in behind (quickly as you can)


Further to the public congratulations to the RSPCA move, emails have been steadily flowing from people who now have something to cling to and can see that they are not on their own in understanding the flaws in BSL as a concept.

For their part the RSPCA is keen to stress its point further. A spokesperson for the organisation told us:

“The focus must be on the deed and not the breed of the animal and enforcement of the law should be made as simple and effective as possible to ensure that local authorities and police services take action.

Section 1 of the Dangerous Dogs Act 1991 has had little effect to stem the number of prohibited dogs in the country and many experts believe there are more in the UK now than in the late 1980s and early 1990s.

The RSPCA is working with politicians to encourage support for such an approach to legislation and hopes in the long-term to be successful in this tact.”

Many will agree, this positive news is a great way to start the new year and let’s hope we can cite 2009 as the year when the legislators and major animal organisations worked together to put an end to the barbaric practice of state controlled killing and seizure of dogs based on nothing more than their size and shape - a practice which has not only cost the tax payer millions of pounds but has NOT reduced the number of dog attacks or improved the safety of the general public at all.
Author Details
Ryan O'Meara is editor-in-chief of K9 Magazine, the lifestyle magazine for dog lovers. He lives in the East Midlands with his own two dogs, Mia and Chloe.



Finally I've been published! tongue.gif
Veanna
That is brilliant news. I really hope the rest of the world follows.

Well done RSPCA UK!
Erny
QUOTE (rhapsodical78 @ 9th Jan 2009 - 12:20 AM) *
Finally I've been published! tongue.gif


laugh.gif .... your payment can be the relinquishment of BSL biggrin.gif. That would be worth a mint biggrin.gif.
rhapsodical78
QUOTE (Erny @ 9th Jan 2009 - 07:28 PM) *
QUOTE (rhapsodical78 @ 9th Jan 2009 - 12:20 AM) *
Finally I've been published! tongue.gif


laugh.gif .... your payment can be the relinquishment of BSL biggrin.gif. That would be worth a mint biggrin.gif.


That would be the ultimate christmas bonus.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2010 Invision Power Services, Inc.