Jump to content

What Breed?


Lloyd
 Share

Recommended Posts

I'm looking for a breed that has similar traits to the German Shepherd Dog but doesn't shed so heavily or have to look similar. Also a breeds that's either medium in size and weight to large. And not vicious or hard to train and can be found in Australia.

Edited by Lloyd
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 46
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Trainability, Loyalty, Responsive, Doesn't bark too much, Doesn't Shed or Drool Much, Not High-strung, Willing to work, Even Temperament, Won't try to kill livestock or small animals, Not to small a dog, Doesn't have a tendency to bite, Can spend a lot of time outside or by itself if needed, Can think for itself like a GSD

Link to comment
Share on other sites

..do you have plans for a new dog? Obedience?Guard? House pet? Show?Jogging companion?

What you have listed are pretty much what everyone is looking for ....a pretty much 'perfect' dog ;)

Some traits are genetic, some individual personality, some breed,and some are only after training.

It's always tricky to find 'the' one - glad you are researching.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Trainability, Loyalty, Responsive, Doesn't bark too much, Doesn't Shed or Drool Much, Not High-strung, Willing to work, Even Temperament, Won't try to kill livestock or small animals, Not to small a dog, Doesn't have a tendency to bite, Can spend a lot of time outside or by itself if needed, Can think for itself like a GSD

Sorry, but I cannot think of a breed that could meet these requirements. I think you want an angel, not a dog :laugh:

If you want a people focussed, loyal and responsive dog, it won't want to spend a lot of time by itself. Fine for working hours (God knows we all have to do those) but you need to make room in your life for a dog.

Barking and biting are partly about breed but frankly a lot more about how much socialisation, physical and mental stimulation a dog gets. A dog that spends a lot of time alone, outside, won't get that.

Any working breed with prey drive (like a GSD) that is not well socialised and managed with small animals and livestock may exhibit that prey drive in ways you will not like. The more time the dog spends outside without human supervision, the more chance it will hve to exercise that drive. And if its the kind of dog that can think for itself, it will be even better equiped to amuse itself in ways dogs enjoy.

If you are not prepared to put a lot of time and effort into socialising and training a dog AND spending time with it, I'd not recommend a GSD, any dog like a GSD or indeed any dog at all.

Sorry, but that's the reality of being a responsible dog owner and of having a happy dog. Perhaps I'm missing something from your listed characteristics but this sounds like a bit of a disaster to me.

Edited by Haredown Whippets
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Can spend a lot of time outside or by itself if needed,

The Belgian Shepherd (of any variety) is a people dog. They need their people & need to be interacting with you, even if you are only sitting at the computer. This breed will not thrive if left for long hours in the backyard, & do not make good kennel dogs for the same reason.

Can think for itself like a GSD

The Belgian is extraordinarily intuitive, knows when you are happy or sad, & unfortunately knows when you are nervous or not in control. Highly intelligent - they will keep you on your toes & you need to have a good sense of humour!

Doesn't bark too much,

Won't try to kill livestock or small animals,

This is where you come in - it's called training!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What are you planning on doing with the dog? Those requirements could be many breeds or none, as Haredown Whippets said a lot is down to training, management, how much time you spend with the dog, and what you want to do.

Eg Willing to work - that is very open - work doing what? sports like obedience/agility/flyball? Herding? Protection? Gundog work?

Not high strung, an even temperament - even within breeds temperament can vary a lot, this is where research into breeders and lines of dogs is useful.

Doesn't shed or drool much - then you can discount many breeds with double coats and brachycephalic breeds

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You might want to prioritise your list, some of the traits you mentioned are rarely found in the same dog.

Like loyal and capable of spending a lot of time alone

The most loyal dogs are the ones that want to be with their human a lot, ones that are happy to spend time alone are usually more independent.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You might want to prioritise your list, some of the traits you mentioned are rarely found in the same dog.

Like loyal and capable of spending a lot of time alone

The most loyal dogs are the ones that want to be with their human a lot, ones that are happy to spend time alone are usually more independent.

No, loyal and independent are not mutually exclusive.

A loyal and independent dog will often be only loyal to one human.

That the dog is aloof does not diminish the loyalty,

it may even make their loyalty more significant :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not a Kelpie expert, but my friend's Kelpies have a lot of those traits you find desirable.

However both dogs are inside/outside dogs (access to both 24/7), and both have been trained and socialized extensively. Both Humans work full time, but a lot of the time they are not working is devoted to activities with the dogs. They also still had some destruction when they were young dogs.

edit for clarity

Edited by raineth
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yes as Raineth said, my kelpie fits everything you said to a tee BUT she was carefully chosen as a quieter more focused pup and I spent A LOT of time training her, particularly in the first 8 months or so, after that things were a lot more relaxed. If you can't commit to working extra hard during that formative period in order to ensure the dog grows up the way you want it I wouldn't get a working breed pup.

Other option might be to look for an older dog being rehomed who is already used to being home alone a fair bit, depends whether you really want a pup though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yes as Raineth said, my kelpie fits everything you said to a tee BUT she was carefully chosen as a quieter more focused pup and I spent A LOT of time training her, particularly in the first 8 months or so, after that things were a lot more relaxed. If you can't commit to working extra hard during that formative period in order to ensure the dog grows up the way you want it I wouldn't get a working breed pup.

Other option might be to look for an older dog being rehomed who is already used to being home alone a fair bit, depends whether you really want a pup though.

Yes, the Kelpies who are raised well, actually seem to bridge the gap between biddability/loyalty and adapting quite well to alone time.

But by 'alone time' I don't mean stuck in the backyard with an hour of contact with the family a day. I just mean, they seem to cope well with the time alone while their owners are at work :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

None of the Kelpies discussed so far in this thread are ever alone. They have canine company.

Actually, their first Kelpie was raised alone. She is a dog that has not the least bit of interest in other dogs. She was about 13 I think when they got the second kelpie pup. So the second has definitely not been raised alone.

However you make a very valid point as, many dogs do benefit substantially from the companionship of other dogs.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Kelpies are not like GSDs lol I have both.

Although with both breeds choosing your breeder carefully is important because some individuals of both breeds can be highly strung and/or have poor temperaments.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Trainability, Loyalty, Responsive, Doesn't bark too much, Doesn't Shed or Drool Much, Not High-strung, Willing to work, Even Temperament, Won't try to kill livestock or small animals, Not to small a dog, Doesn't have a tendency to bite, Can spend a lot of time outside or by itself if needed, Can think for itself like a GSD

Apart from the bit bolded above, you have described a Border Collie. Any loyal and highly trainable breed will want to be with their trainer, not stuck alone in a yard. Many dogs cope alone while the owner is at work but if they spend that time alone, they should be with the family the rest of the time.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share


×
×
  • Create New...