Jump to content

Recall Plan and Recall Lead length - Queries

6 posts in this topic

I have Lucy, a beautiful14 month old kelpie-staffy cross we rescued last year. We took her to dog obedience training for 3 months and she has done well, but one thing we haven't got yet is excellent recall with distractions (We don't even have reasonable recall with distractions). When we call, she just races past us, close but not close enough for contact, and goes around and around running at turbo speed for about 3-5 minutes, and then as she comes past she will plonk down and let us put a lead on her. We know to release her again so she doesn't associate the lead with end of fun. We are determined (husband, adult son and I) to put in as much effort as is required to get excellent recall in place with our girl.


My plan is to 

- practice and train at home with a 10m lead, then a 25m lead

- have treats only used for recall training (highly enticing treats - bought some duck sticks today I'll try

- once her recall is good on the 10m lead, I'll progress to the 25m lead


Question 1

- when I call and she does not come, I will call once more and then if she doesn't come I will quietly reel her back in. No treat.


Is this right? 

And once I reel her back in, do we stop recall training? Or do I try again. I don't know what to do.


Also, I can't many leads over 30m. 

Should I find a 50M to train with or should I not need that? Once she is on the 30m lead and recalling reliably, I can then trial her in quiet off lead parks with low distraction and work up from there?


Any advice would be so appreciated.

Recall is quite the challenge!!



Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

There's probably quite a few different ways to approach recall but I was reading an article this morning which is simple and straight forward.  Its super long but hopefully there's soome snippets in here you might like?  (It's from Volhard.com).

Rule #1: Exercise, exercise, exercise.

Many dogs do not come when called because they do not get enough exercise.  At every chance, they run off and make the most of it by staying out for hours at a time. 

Consider what your dog was bred to do and that will tell you how much exercise he needs.  Just putting him out in the backyard will not do.  You will have to participate.  Think of it this way, exercise is as good for you as it is for your dog. 


Rule #2: Whenever your dog comes to you, be nice to him. 

One of the quickest ways to teach your dog not to come to you is to call him to punish him or do something the dog perceives as unpleasant.  Most dogs consider being given a bath or a pill unpleasant.  When he needs either, go and get him instead of calling him to you. 

Another example of teaching your dog not to come is to take him for a run in the park and call him to you when it's time to go home.  Repeating this sequence several times, teaches the dog "the party is over!"  Soon, he may become reluctant to return to you when called because he is not ready to end the fun. 

You can prevent this kind of unintentional training by calling him to you several times during his outing, sometimes giving him a treat, sometimes just a pat on the head.  Then let him romp again. 


Rule #3: Teach him to come when called as soon as you get him, no matter how young he is. 

Ideally, you acquired your dog as a puppy and that is the best time to teach him to come when called.  Start right away.  But remember, sometime between the 4th and 8th months of age, your puppy will begin to realize there is a big, wide world out there.  While he is going through this stage, it is best to keep him on leash so that he does not learn he can ignore you when you call him.  


Rule #4: When in doubt, keep him on leash. 

Learn to anticipate when your dog is likely not to come.  You may be tempting fate trying to call him once he has spotted a cat, another dog, or a jogger.  Of course, there will be times when you goof and let him go just as another dog appears out of nowhere. 

Resist the urge to make a complete fool of yourself by bellowing "come" a million times.  The more often you holler "come," the quicker he learns he can ignore you when he is off leash.Instead, turn your back to him and calmly walk away. When he catches up to you, give him a treat as you put your left hand under his chin, palm facing up, through his collar and then put him on leash.  Do not get angry with him once you have caught him or you will make him afraid of you and he will run away from you when you try to catch him the next time. 

Rule #5: Make sure your dog always comes to you and lets you touch his collar before you reward him with a treat or praise.

Touching his collar prevents the dog from developing the annoying habit of playing "catch" - coming towards you and then dancing around you, just out of reach. 


The Game of Coming When Called

Needed:  two people, one hungry dog, one six foot leash and plenty of small treats.

Step 1: inside the house, with your dog on a six-foot leash, you and your partner sit on the floor or ground, six feet apart, facing each other.  Your partner gently hangs on to the dog, you hold the end of the leash.  Call your dog by saying "name,  come," and use the leash to guide him to you.  Put your hand through his collar, give him a treat, pet and praise him enthusiastically. 

Now you hold the dog and pass the leash to your partner who says "name..come," guides the dog in, puts his hand through the collar, gives him a treat,  and praises the dog.  

Goal: repeat until your dog responds to being called on his own and no longer needs to be guided in with leash.

Step 2: repeat Step 1 with your dog off leash. 

Goal: gradually increase distance between you and your partner to 12 feet. 

Step 3: have your partner hold your dog (off leash) while you hide from him (go into another room), then call your dog.  When he finds you, put your hand through the collar, give him a treat, and praise him.  If he can't find you, go to him, take him by the collar and bring him to the spot where you called.  Reward and praise.  Now have your partner hide and then call him. 

Goal:  Repeat until the dog doesn't hesitate in finding you or your partner in any room of the house. 


Going Outside

Take your dog outside to a confined area, such as a fenced yard, tennis court, park or schoolyard and repeat Steps 1, 2 and 3. 

You are now ready to practice by yourself.  Let your dog loose in a confined area and ignore him.  When he is not paying any attention to you, call him.  When he gets to you, give him a treat and make a big fuss over him.  If he does not come, go to him, take him by his collar and bring him to the spot where you called him where you then reward and praise him. 

Repeat until he comes to you every time you call him. 

Once your dog is trained, you don't have to reward him with a treat every time, but do so frequently. 


Adding Distractions

Some dogs will need to be trained to come in the face of distractions such as other dogs, children, joggers, food, or friendly strangers.  Think about the the most irresistible situations for your dog and then practice under those circumstances. 


On Leash

Step 1: Put a 12' leash on your dog (this can be two six' leashes tied together) and take him to an area where he is likely to encounter his favorite distraction.  Once he spots it (jogger, bicycle, other dog, whatever), let him become thoroughly engrossed, either by watching or straining at his leash, and give the command "name, come."  More than likely, he will ignore you.  Give a sharp tug on the leash and guide him back to you.  Praise and pet him enthusiastically. 

Goal: Repeat 3 times per session until the dog turns and comes to you immediately when you call.  If he does not, you may have to change your training equipment.  (See, Chapter 9, Alternatives.) 

Note:  Some dogs quickly learn to avoid the distraction by staying close to you, which is fine.  Tell him what a clever fellow he is and then try with a different distraction at another time. 

Step 2: Repeat Step 1 in different locations with as many different distractions as you can find.  Try it with someone offering your dog a tidbit as a distraction (the dog is not to get the treat)­­, someone petting the dog and anything else that may distract him.  Use your imagination. 

Goal: A dog that comes immediately when called even when distracted.  


Off Leash Distractions

How you approach this part of the training will depend on your individual circumstances.  Here is an example.  Take your dog to an area where you are not likely to encounter distractions in the form of other dogs or people.  Let him off leash and become involved in a smell in the grass or a tree.  Keep the distance between you and him about 10'.  Call him to you.  If he responds, praise him enthusiastically.  If not, avoid the temptation to call him again.  Don't worry, he heard you, but chose to ignore you. Instead, slowly walk up behind him, firmly take him by his collar, under his chin, palm up, and trot backwards to the spot where you called him.  Then praise him.  

Once he is reliable at this point, try him in an area with other distractions.  If he does not respond, practice for the correct response with the 12' leash before you try him off leash again. 

Can you now trust him to come to you in an unconfined area?  That will depend on how well you have done your homework and what your dog may encounter in the "real" world.  Understanding your dog and what interests him will help you know when he is likely not to respond to being called. 

Let common sense be your guide.  For example, when you are traveling and have to let him out to relieve himself at a busy interstate rest stop, it would be foolhardy to let him run loose.  Remember Rule #4: when in doubt, keep him on leash. 



1) If your dog does not come when called, you don't have a dog. 

2) Whenever your dog comes to you, be nice to him. 

3) When in doubt, keep him on leash.

4) Always touch his collar after he has come to you and before you reward him. 

5) Teach him to come when called now.

6) "Come" is one of the most important commands you will teach your dog. 



Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Just a thought.   I personally wouldn't reel the pup in.   In a situation where you have called and she hasn't responded, I would be walking to her .. "Oh dear, how sad, you missed your chance of a reward."   Then try again, but not letting her go as far.


But before that I would be working along the lines of your plan, starting short ish in low distraction areas, and using a marker (clicker or voice)  to mark when she responds to your calling her (recall) name.   Then telling her how super she is as she rockets back in for her reward - treats, toy play (even better).  (You will have already built up a really big reward history for that name in the house and yard, so that she associates hearing that name with getting a super reward, and then probably being released again.  RInse and repeat.)     As you see her starting to respond really reliably to that name, and you've got your timing and reward delivery down pat, then you can start taking it on the road.


Couple of things about this ... it's not like the formal obedience recall, where the dog has to come right in to you.  That's a separate game.   This one is about the dog including you in the picture, hence marking the head turn response to recall name.   In case you did want to do some formal obedience later, it's a good idea to have a separate emergency recall name, rather than using the dog's name, as in competition, you don't want the dog moving on her name.   The emergency/play recall name should be short, sharp, with hard consonants, and something you can yell easily.   So my BC Rory's emergency recall name is Big.


And the other thing .. it's best not to put her in a situation where she has the opportunity to reinforce herself by ignoring you and running around like an idiot.   So that means, during the training process, you'll have a long line on her.   It can be just literally a long line .. attached to a lead handle is good so that you don't risk rope burn.


Having said all this, there are different ways of achieving the end goal.   Others will probably be along with some other ideas.


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Sooo many ways you can teach recall, and it depends on what you want from your dog when they are offlead also - is it an opportunity for zoomies, do you want them to walk near by, can they go off and sniff and then come back, etc, etc, etc?!

Anyway, I reward my dogs every time they come back to me when we are out and they are off lead.  If I call them and they come in super fast they get a great reward, but if they come to check in they get a reward, if they come when called they get a reward.  I have found with my lot that gets them in to me consistently.  And when I don't have a reward they don't know that, so still come in anyway!

I do recalls on their normal walking lead first, then progress to a long lead and then a 25m lead.  And at the same time as this try to find fenced areas where we can practice our recalls.

When I tech recalls I do a lot of what I call "bouncing" - call the dog, reward somehow for coming to you and send them off again straight away.  When we do "bouncing" there is no stopping, no need to sit, etc the dog just needs to come to the person close enough that they could grab their collar and then they are released to keep walking straight away.  I do this on a normal lead and while we are just doing normal walking.

And I think one of the keys things is make it as fun as you can and mix it up.  If it becomes predictable and boring no one will want to do it.  Make it a game and keep having fun!

  • Like 2

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

An online course I'm doing has a challenge at the moment .. see if you can get in 15 recalls a day with your dog ... short, long, wherever the dog is up to  .. so 15 opportunities to reward!   That's a lot of deposits in the recall bank. :rofl:  Can be in the house, outside in the yard .. depends on where the dog is up to.   Fun challenge.


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

I've been using the TOT (stickied) feeding time as recall training. Built up her impulse control to a point that we could place the dinner at any given distance and trust she would not help herself for a period of time. Would maintain eye contact, and pump out behaviour on cue (drop, sit, spin, paw, target, etc). Had also previously been training her recall with methods described above to the point where she knew what the cue 'come' meant. Started with small distances at dinner and building up. Strong recall and bounces back to her reward.


Also use the high value and make games with the wife/kids in the backyard. Call her name and when she's got that stance/look that you're condifent she's going to come drop the cue and wait for arrival. In this we try to hide the reward and only show it once she arrives (not using it to bribe), but I think she adequately knows 'the game'. 

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now